Residential Property Data Records on Shay Rd, Middlesex, NY

We found 7 addresses on Shay Rd, Middlesex, NY.

1212 Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $347,000
Living Area 3,178 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1886

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 23.03-1-16
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

1213 Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $216,000
Living Area 1,088 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1999

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 23.03-1-26
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

1266 Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $300,000
Living Area 2,304 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1993

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 23.03-1-15
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Purchase Price $62,000
Lot SqFt. 550,163

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Residential Vacant Land
Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 23.03-1-17
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Assessed Value $130,200
Lot SqFt. 2,025,976

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Crops
Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 32.02-1-9.1
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Purchase Price $200
Lot SqFt. 627,264

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Residential Vacant Land
Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 32.04-1-13
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Assessed Value $38,400
Lot SqFt. 662,112

Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A

Property Type Crops
Ownership Type Mixed

APN 572800 33.01-1-13
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Investment Properties near on Shay Rd, Middlesex, NY

1527 Phelps RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $231,000
Living Area 596 SqFt

Beds 1
Baths 1
Year Built 1976

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 573289 33.02-1-5
Municipality POTTER (TOV)

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

570 E Lake RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $1,854,000
Living Area 3,890 SqFt

Beds 6
Baths 3.5
Year Built 1987

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 11.35-1-7
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

161A Timberlane RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $209,000
Living Area 768 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1959

Property Type Cabin/Vacation Residence
Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 11.83-1-21
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

5199 Sunflower RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $241,000
Living Area 528 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1968

Property Type Cabin/Vacation Residence
Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 23.72-1-5
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

1249 Phelps RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $134,000
Living Area 890 SqFt

Beds 1
Baths 1
Year Built 1930

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 573289 24.71-1-2
Municipality POTTER (TOV)

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

5210 Red Clover RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $414,000
Living Area 1,600 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2.5
Year Built 2021

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 13.03-1-4
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

5601 Water StMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $214,000
Living Area 1,112 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 1
Year Built 1885

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple

APN 572800 22.67-1-4
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

1212 Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $329,000
Living Area 3,178 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1886

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 23.03-1-16
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

6058 S Hill RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $307,000
Living Area 1,800 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 2007

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 22.03-1-13.211
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

4706 State Route 364Middlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $208,000
Living Area 1,012 SqFt

Beds 1
Baths 1
Year Built 1988

Property Type Cabin/Vacation Residence
Ownership Type Mixed

APN 573289 24.01-1-5
Municipality POTTER (TOV)

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

5549 Water StMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $166,000
Living Area 1,798 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1875

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 22.68-1-32
Subdivision 8th Range Of Farms

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

116 E Lake RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $363,000
Living Area 960 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1945

Property Type Cabin/Vacation Residence
Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 2.38-1-6
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

1204 Mill StMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $186,000
Living Area 2,172 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 22.67-1-15
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

6048 N Vine Valley RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $360,000
Living Area 1,456 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2.5
Year Built 1992

Property Type Rural Residence
Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 12.01-1-15.1
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

5170 Sunnyside RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $650,000
Living Area 1,206 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1.5
Year Built 2021

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 572400 43.46-1-16
Municipality ITALY

School District Naples Central School District

1124 Mertz RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $283,000
Living Area 2,020 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1900

Property Type Rural Residence
Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 22.03-1-6
Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Streets Near Shay Rd, Middlesex, NY

Street

Properties

Avg. Beds

Avg. Baths

Avg. Property Value

Avg. Property Size

Last Sale Date

Cliffside Dr18422$385,9321,474 Sq.Ft.4/14/2025Friend Rd5532$345,7141,826 Sq.Ft.1/10/2025Lake Rd15232$933,6761,736 Sq.Ft.2/11/2025Lake Rd4832$677,9071,459 Sq.Ft.10/30/2024Main St12432$209,0632,117 Sq.Ft.1/24/2025Route 2455131$323,7506,309 Sq.Ft.1/31/2025Seneca Point Rd7643$1,722,4563,092 Sq.Ft.11/25/2024State Route 3645331$274,8051,669 Sq.Ft.1/27/2023Vine Valley Rd9732$328,5071,561 Sq.Ft.2/21/2024West Ave5531$195,2051,235 Sq.Ft.11/5/2024

Additional Questions?

Looking for off-market properties in Middlesex, NY?

Traditional methods include networking with contractors, scouting neighborhoods ("driving for dollars"), or purchasing leads from wholesalers can be tedious. PropertyReach streamlines this process with predictive analytics and neighborhood benchmarks, using Middlesex, NY property records and MLS failed listings to refine your search. Effortlessly compare properties, access owner contact details, and secure the best off-market deals at the right price.

What is the median home value in Middlesex, NY?

The median home value in Middlesex, NY is $278,000, with an average home value of $444,136. The average price per square foot for homes in the area is $122.94.

How Can I Find Pre-foreclosures or Distressed Properties in Middlesex, NY?

Foreclosures and distressed properties in Middlesex, NY can be found through public records, foreclosure notices, and auction announcements from the county clerk or sheriff’s office. PropertyReach streamlines this by aggregating public and MLS data, making it easier to identify distressed properties and connect with owners directly.

Residential Property Data Records on Shay Rd, Middlesex, NY

We found 7 addresses on Shay Rd, Middlesex, NY.

1212 Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $347,000

Living Area 3,178 SqFt

Beds 3

Baths 2

Year Built 1886

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 23.03-1-16

Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

1213 Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $216,000

Living Area 1,088 SqFt

Beds 2

Baths 1

Year Built 1999

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 23.03-1-26

Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

1266 Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Estimated Value $300,000

Living Area 2,304 SqFt

Beds 3

Baths 1.5

Year Built 1993

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 23.03-1-15

Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Purchase Price $62,000

Lot SqFt. 550,163

Beds N/A

Baths N/A

Year Built N/A

Property Type Residential Vacant Land

Ownership Type Related

APN 572800 23.03-1-17

Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Assessed Value $130,200

Lot SqFt. 2,025,976

Beds N/A

Baths N/A

Year Built N/A

Property Type Crops

Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 32.02-1-9.1

Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Purchase Price $200

Lot SqFt. 627,264

Beds N/A

Baths N/A

Year Built N/A

Property Type Residential Vacant Land

Ownership Type Individual

APN 572800 32.04-1-13

Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Shay RdMiddlesex, NY 14507

Assessed Value $38,400

Lot SqFt. 662,112

Beds N/A

Baths N/A

Year Built N/A

Property Type Crops

Ownership Type Mixed

APN 572800 33.01-1-13

Municipality MIDDLESEX

School District Gorham-Middlesex Central School District (Marcus Whitman)

Trial Membership Gives You Complete Data Access

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A

Beds
N/A

Baths
N/A

Year Built
N/A