Try our
Lite Plan
for only $29 a month
Free Trial
Search
Features
Pricing
Customers
Contact
Log In
FREE Trial
Home
Search
Features
Pricing
Customers
About Us
Contact
Log In
Gardiner Way Shelter Island NY Property Records
Residential Property Data Records on
Gardiner Way, Shelter Island, NY
We found
6
addresses on Gardiner Way, Shelter Island, NY.
2 Gardiner Way
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$2,600,000
Living Area
2,766 SqFt
Beds
6
Baths
3.5
Year Built
1885
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0701-001.00-02.00-008.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
3 Gardiner Way
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,670,000
Living Area
2,953 SqFt
Beds
6
Baths
3
Year Built
1880
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0701-001.00-02.00-007.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4 Gardiner Way
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,729,000
Living Area
2,506 SqFt
Beds
5
Baths
2
Year Built
1860
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
0701-001.00-02.00-009.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
5 Gardiner Way
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$4,384,000
Living Area
3,771 SqFt
Beds
6
Baths
2.5
Year Built
1883
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Related
APN
0701-001.00-02.00-006.001
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
6 Gardiner Way
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$2,641,000
Living Area
2,753 SqFt
Beds
5
Baths
3.5
Year Built
1886
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0701-001.00-02.00-012.001
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
8 Gardiner Way
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$2,727,000
Living Area
4,053 SqFt
Beds
5
Baths
3.5
Year Built
1887
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Related
APN
0701-001.00-02.00-014.001
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
7 Day FREE Trial Gives You Complete Data Access
Property Lookup
Retrieve an in-depth view of a property’s characteristics and situational data.
Owner Lookup
Lookup by name or number to view all properties historically linked to an individual.
Property Search
Search for a list of properties based on location and 130+ criteria filters.
Owner Contact Information
Access phone numbers and email addresses associated with property owners, relatives and associates.
Property Comps
Pull a list of property comparables using multi-sourced data and stackable filters.
Market Trends
View a variety of up-to-date market trends and statistics by location.
Get Started Today
Investment Properties near on
Gardiner Way, Shelter Island, NY
410 Sound Dr
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$759,000
Living Area
1,542 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
2
Year Built
1965
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
1000-035.00-01.00-016.000
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
123 Sterling Ave #5
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,248,000
Living Area
1,484 SqFt
Beds
2
Baths
2.5
Year Built
2021
Property Type
Apt House 5+ Units
Ownership Type
Multiple
APN
1001-003.02-02.00-005.000
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
147 Bay Ave
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,148,000
Living Area
1,700 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
3
Year Built
1900
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Multiple
APN
1001-005.00-03.00-004.000
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
311 5th St
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,009,000
Living Area
2,200 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
2
Year Built
1900
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
1001-006.00-07.00-010.000
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
455 Knapp Pl
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$642,000
Living Area
1,050 SqFt
Beds
2
Baths
1
Year Built
1940
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Multiple
APN
1000-034.00-02.00-014.000
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
13F Stirling Cv
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,121,000
Living Area
1,300 SqFt
Beds
2
Baths
2
Year Built
1985
Property Type
Apt House 5+ Units
Ownership Type
Related
APN
1001-003.01-01.00-013.000
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
424 4th St
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,118,000
Living Area
1,972 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
2
Year Built
1973
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Related
APN
1001-006.00-06.00-017.000
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
719 Brown St
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,620,000
Living Area
2,300 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
2
Year Built
2001
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Related
APN
1000-048.00-03.00-042.006
Neighborhood
Greenport West
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
428 2nd St
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$761,000
Living Area
1,100 SqFt
Beds
4
Baths
3
Year Built
1830
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Multiple
APN
1001-004.00-02.00-027.000
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
541 Main St
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$838,000
Living Area
6,098 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
3
Year Built
1880
Property Type
Duplex 2 Units
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
1001-004.00-03.00-022.006
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
432 1st St
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,087,000
Living Area
2,400 SqFt
Beds
4
Baths
2.5
Year Built
1888
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
1001-004.00-07.00-002.001
Subdivision
Beebe Ests
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
516 Main St
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,261,000
Living Area
838 SqFt
Beds
1
Baths
1.5
Year Built
1860
Property Type
Apt House 5+ Units
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
1001-004.00-03.00-029.000
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
63A Shore Rd
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$2,967,000
Living Area
1,914 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
2
Year Built
1987
Property Type
Manufactured Homes
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0900-376.00-03.00-018.000
Municipality
SOUTHAMPTON
School District
Westhampton Beach Union Free School District
1275 Ruch Ln
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,451,000
Living Area
4,780 SqFt
Beds
5
Baths
4
Year Built
1972
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
1000-052.00-03.00-014.001
Municipality
SOUTHOLD
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
360 South St
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,214,000
Living Area
2,762 SqFt
Beds
4
Baths
3
Year Built
1988
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0500-450.00-03.00-007.002
Municipality
ISLIP
School District
East Islip Union Free School District
190 Anglers Rd
Greenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value
$1,149,000
Living Area
2,044 SqFt
Beds
4
Baths
2
Year Built
1971
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
1000-043.00-01.00-004.000
Neighborhood
Greenport West
School District
Greenport Union Free School District
Streets Near
Gardiner Way, Shelter Island, NY
Street
Properties
Avg. Beds
Avg. Baths
Avg. Property Value
Avg. Property Size
Last Sale Date
1st St
50
4
2
$921,326
2,451 Sq.Ft.
6/26/2024
3rd St
49
4
2
$817,733
7,111 Sq.Ft.
2/12/2025
Country Club Dr
44
3
3
$1,660,698
2,579 Sq.Ft.
2/7/2025
Front St
67
5
3
$1,196,000
6,067 Sq.Ft.
1/24/2024
Gardiners Bay Dr
61
4
3
$2,201,411
4,780 Sq.Ft.
12/23/2024
Neck Rd
91
3
2
$1,612,221
3,206 Sq.Ft.
8/8/2024
Route 25
78
3
2
$923,821
13,371 Sq.Ft.
11/1/2024
Shipyard Ln
103
2
2
$1,087,944
5,520 Sq.Ft.
8/13/2024
Sterling Ave
45
3
3
$1,102,600
2,204 Sq.Ft.
1/16/2025
Stirling Cv
46
2
2
$1,340,190
1,469 Sq.Ft.
5/29/2024
Additional Questions?
Looking for off-market properties in Shelter Island, NY?
Traditional methods include networking with contractors, scouting neighborhoods ("driving for dollars"), or purchasing leads from wholesalers can be tedious. PropertyReach streamlines this process with predictive analytics and neighborhood benchmarks, using Shelter Island, NY property records and MLS failed listings to refine your search. Effortlessly compare properties, access owner contact details, and secure the best off-market deals at the right price.
What is the median home value in Shelter Island, NY?
The median home value in Shelter Island, NY is $1,670,000, with an average home value of $2,205,947. The average price per square foot for homes in the area is $448.95.
How Can I Find Pre-foreclosures or Distressed Properties in Shelter Island, NY?
Foreclosures and distressed properties in Shelter Island, NY can be found through public records, foreclosure notices, and auction announcements from the county clerk or sheriff’s office. PropertyReach streamlines this by aggregating public and MLS data, making it easier to identify distressed properties and connect with owners directly.
Try PropertyReach for FREE