Try our
Lite Plan
for only $29 a month
Free Trial
Search
Features
Pricing
Customers
Contact
Log In
FREE Trial
Home
Search
Features
Pricing
Customers
About Us
Contact
Log In
Myrtle Rd Shelter Island NY Property Records
Residential Property Data Records on
Myrtle Rd, Shelter Island, NY
We found
7
addresses on Myrtle Rd, Shelter Island, NY.
2 Myrtle Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Assessed Value
$100
Lot SqFt.
5,227
Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A
Property Type
Roads, Streets, Bridges
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
0700-012.00-01.00-030.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
2 Myrtle Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Assessed Value
$100
Lot SqFt.
5,227
Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A
Property Type
Transportation
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
0702-012.00-01.00-030.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
43 Myrtle Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$647,000
Living Area
3,327 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
3
Year Built
1993
Property Type
Residential Vacant Land
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
0702-012.00-01.00-012.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
43 Myrtle Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Purchase Price
$295,000
Lot SqFt.
11,761
Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A
Property Type
Residential Vacant Land
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
473289 12.-1-12
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
45 Myrtle Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,015,000
Living Area
798 SqFt
Beds
1
Baths
1
Year Built
1939
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
0702-012.00-01.00-015.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
64 Myrtle Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Purchase Price
$305,000
Lot SqFt.
12,197
Beds
N/A
Baths
N/A
Year Built
N/A
Property Type
Residential Vacant Land
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
473289 12.-1-14
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
64 Myrtle Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$655,000
Living Area
2,296 SqFt
Beds
3
Buildings
1
Year Built
1945
Property Type
Residential Vacant Land
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
0702-012.00-01.00-014.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
7 Day FREE Trial Gives You Complete Data Access
Property Lookup
Retrieve an in-depth view of a property’s characteristics and situational data.
Owner Lookup
Lookup by name or number to view all properties historically linked to an individual.
Property Search
Search for a list of properties based on location and 130+ criteria filters.
Owner Contact Information
Access phone numbers and email addresses associated with property owners, relatives and associates.
Property Comps
Pull a list of property comparables using multi-sourced data and stackable filters.
Market Trends
View a variety of up-to-date market trends and statistics by location.
Get Started Today
Investment Properties near on
Myrtle Rd, Shelter Island, NY
20D N Cartwright Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,798,000
Living Area
1,154 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
1
Year Built
1960
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
0702-016.00-02.00-002.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
90 Gardiners Bay Dr
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$3,117,000
Living Area
5,064 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
5.5
Year Built
2001
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
0702-001.00-02.00-053.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
7 Lari Ln
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$4,074,000
Living Area
4,301 SqFt
Beds
4
Baths
4
Year Built
1988
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Mixed
APN
0702-008.00-03.00-005.013
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
19 Peconic Ave
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,354,000
Living Area
1,431 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
1.5
Year Built
1969
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0702-021.00-01.00-035.002
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
2 Fox Hollow Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$2,178,000
Living Area
5,219 SqFt
Beds
5
Baths
2
Year Built
2018
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0702-019.00-02.00-113.003
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
6 Linda Ct
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,850,000
Living Area
1,884 SqFt
Beds
4
Baths
2
Year Built
1975
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Related
APN
0702-015.00-04.00-041.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
69 S Ram Island Dr
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$3,256,000
Living Area
3,980 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
2.5
Year Built
1988
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Multiple
APN
0702-010.00-01.00-036.025
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
129 N Ferry Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,254,000
Living Area
2,418 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
1.5
Year Built
1920
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0702-007.00-03.00-051.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
22 Merkel Ln
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$3,480,000
Living Area
6,228 SqFt
Beds
4
Baths
4.5
Year Built
1967
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0702-024.00-01.00-030.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
5 Bay Ave
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,304,000
Living Area
1,270 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
3
Year Built
1951
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Related
APN
0702-022.00-02.00-042.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
56 Cobbetts Ln
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,414,000
Living Area
2,398 SqFt
Beds
4
Baths
2.5
Year Built
1984
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0702-003.00-02.00-040.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
8 Wesley Ave
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,386,000
Living Area
2,887 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
3.5
Year Built
1872
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Corporate
APN
0702-005.00-04.00-020.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
6 Petticoat Ln
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$2,271,000
Living Area
2,382 SqFt
Beds
3
Baths
2.5
Year Built
2005
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Multiple
APN
0702-022.00-01.00-018.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
4 Chase Ave
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,353,000
Living Area
2,194 SqFt
Beds
4
Baths
2
Year Built
1890
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Related
APN
0702-005.00-06.00-011.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
11F Petticoat Ln
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,468,000
Living Area
1,908 SqFt
Beds
4
Baths
2
Year Built
1968
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Individual
APN
0702-022.00-01.00-074.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
17 Ram Island Rd
Shelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value
$1,285,000
Living Area
960 SqFt
Beds
2
Baths
1
Year Built
1960
Property Type
Single Family
Ownership Type
Related
APN
0702-008.00-02.00-042.000
Neighborhood
Shelter Island
School District
Shelter Island Union Free School District
Streets Near
Myrtle Rd, Shelter Island, NY
Street
Properties
Avg. Beds
Avg. Baths
Avg. Property Value
Avg. Property Size
Last Sale Date
Cartwright Rd
106
3
2
$1,661,361
1,810 Sq.Ft.
3/4/2025
Country Club Dr
51
3
3
$1,660,698
2,579 Sq.Ft.
2/7/2025
Ferry Rd
269
3
2
$1,744,305
2,858 Sq.Ft.
1/24/2025
Gardiners Bay Dr
61
4
3
$2,201,411
4,780 Sq.Ft.
12/23/2024
Lake Dr
45
3
3
$1,629,341
2,229 Sq.Ft.
2/27/2025
Menantic Rd
93
3
2
$1,655,097
2,030 Sq.Ft.
1/9/2025
Midway Rd
166
3
2
$1,913,154
2,138 Sq.Ft.
12/9/2024
Ram Island Dr
121
4
4
$3,941,286
3,677 Sq.Ft.
3/23/2022
Smith St
52
3
2
$1,549,340
1,564 Sq.Ft.
3/11/2025
Tuthill Dr
70
4
3
$3,123,358
3,893 Sq.Ft.
8/28/2024
Additional Questions?
Looking for off-market properties in Shelter Island, NY?
Traditional methods include networking with contractors, scouting neighborhoods ("driving for dollars"), or purchasing leads from wholesalers can be tedious. PropertyReach streamlines this process with predictive analytics and neighborhood benchmarks, using Shelter Island, NY property records and MLS failed listings to refine your search. Effortlessly compare properties, access owner contact details, and secure the best off-market deals at the right price.
What is the median home value in Shelter Island, NY?
The median home value in Shelter Island, NY is $1,670,000, with an average home value of $2,204,876. The average price per square foot for homes in the area is $445.51.
How Can I Find Pre-foreclosures or Distressed Properties in Shelter Island, NY?
Foreclosures and distressed properties in Shelter Island, NY can be found through public records, foreclosure notices, and auction announcements from the county clerk or sheriff’s office. PropertyReach streamlines this by aggregating public and MLS data, making it easier to identify distressed properties and connect with owners directly.
Try PropertyReach for FREE