Residential Property Data Records on Simpson St, Shelter Island, NY

We found 2 addresses on Simpson St, Shelter Island, NY.

1 Simpson StShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $5,841,000
Living Area 3,634 SqFt

Beds 5
Baths 3.5
Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple

APN 0702-022.00-02.00-051.001
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

4 Simpson StShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,758,000
Living Area 2,151 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2.5
Year Built 1935

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate

APN 0702-022.00-02.00-032.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

Investment Properties near on Simpson St, Shelter Island, NY

20 Osprey RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,459,000
Living Area 2,537 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 3
Year Built 1998

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 0702-023.00-02.00-052.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

68 Gardiners Bay DrShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $2,761,000
Living Area 1,921 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1970

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 0702-001.00-02.00-063.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

30 Winthrop RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,704,000
Living Area 2,766 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 3
Year Built 1965

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate

APN 0702-007.00-04.00-033.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

80 W Neck RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,228,000
Living Area 1,508 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1958

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 0702-014.00-01.00-046.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

12 Petticoat LnShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $2,305,000
Living Area 2,528 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1963

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple

APN 0702-022.00-01.00-021.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

76 N Cartwright RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,996,000
Living Area 2,576 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 2.5
Year Built 1860

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 0702-008.00-03.00-017.003
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

79 N Cartwright RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,225,000
Living Area 768 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1938

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 0702-008.00-03.00-028.001
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

5 Lakeview DrShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,364,000
Living Area 2,004 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1978

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple

APN 0702-019.00-02.00-041.003
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

105 N Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,565,000
Living Area 2,900 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1847

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 0702-014.00-04.00-004.005
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

16 Lake DrShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,371,000
Living Area 1,885 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1977

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 0702-019.00-01.00-097.001
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

3 Tims TrlShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,428,000
Living Area 1,647 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 2
Year Built 1979

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 0702-017.00-02.00-012.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

104 Gardiners Bay DrShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,473,000
Living Area 1,941 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 2
Year Built 1985

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Mixed

APN 0702-001.00-02.00-001.003
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

3 Peppermill LnShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,332,000
Living Area 1,361 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1986

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple

APN 0702-019.00-02.00-080.019
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

22 Sunshine RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,729,000
Living Area 1,472 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1950

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 0702-019.00-01.00-090.003
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

53 N Cartwright RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,543,000
Living Area 2,052 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 2.5
Year Built 1930

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple

APN 0702-008.00-03.00-045.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island

Subdivision Shelter Island Grove

129 N Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,254,000
Living Area 2,418 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1920

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 0702-007.00-03.00-051.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

Streets Near Simpson St, Shelter Island, NY

Street

Properties

Avg. Beds

Avg. Baths

Avg. Property Value

Avg. Property Size

Last Sale Date

Brander Pkwy9333$2,106,5002,261 Sq.Ft.12/30/2022Cartwright Rd10732$1,665,4171,859 Sq.Ft.4/11/2025Cedar Dr5632$955,4001,954 Sq.Ft.12/30/2024Ferry Rd26932$1,889,0842,892 Sq.Ft.1/24/2025Menantic Rd9032$1,858,7322,031 Sq.Ft.1/9/2025Midway Rd16832$1,960,1252,160 Sq.Ft.3/12/2025Neck Rd9232$1,577,6973,247 Sq.Ft.8/8/2024Peconic Ave9743$2,445,3632,676 Sq.Ft.9/12/2024Smith St5232$1,482,9801,593 Sq.Ft.3/11/2025Westmoreland Dr5144$3,570,6603,674 Sq.Ft.3/5/2024

Additional Questions?

Looking for off-market properties in Shelter Island, NY?

Traditional methods include networking with contractors, scouting neighborhoods ("driving for dollars"), or purchasing leads from wholesalers can be tedious. PropertyReach streamlines this process with predictive analytics and neighborhood benchmarks, using Shelter Island, NY property records and MLS failed listings to refine your search. Effortlessly compare properties, access owner contact details, and secure the best off-market deals at the right price.

What is the median home value in Shelter Island, NY?

The median home value in Shelter Island, NY is $1,741,000, with an average home value of $2,300,398. The average price per square foot for homes in the area is $438.58.

How Can I Find Pre-foreclosures or Distressed Properties in Shelter Island, NY?

Foreclosures and distressed properties in Shelter Island, NY can be found through public records, foreclosure notices, and auction announcements from the county clerk or sheriff’s office. PropertyReach streamlines this by aggregating public and MLS data, making it easier to identify distressed properties and connect with owners directly.

Residential Property Data Records on Simpson St, Shelter Island, NY

We found 2 addresses on Simpson St, Shelter Island, NY.

1 Simpson StShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $5,841,000

Living Area 3,634 SqFt

Beds 5

Baths 3.5

Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Multiple

APN 0702-022.00-02.00-051.001

Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

4 Simpson StShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,758,000

Living Area 2,151 SqFt

Beds 3

Baths 2.5

Year Built 1935

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Corporate

APN 0702-022.00-02.00-032.000

Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

Trial Membership Gives You Complete Data Access

Property Lookup

Owner Lookup

Property Search

Owner Contact Information

Property Comps

Market Trends

Investment Properties near on Simpson St, Shelter Island, NY

20 Osprey RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,459,000

Living Area 2,537 SqFt

Beds 3

Baths 3

Year Built 1998

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Related

APN 0702-023.00-02.00-052.000

Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

68 Gardiners Bay DrShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $2,761,000

Living Area 1,921 SqFt

Beds 3

Baths 2

Year Built 1970

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Related

APN 0702-001.00-02.00-063.000

Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

30 Winthrop RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,704,000

Living Area 2,766 SqFt

Beds 3

Baths 3

Year Built 1965

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Corporate

APN 0702-007.00-04.00-033.000

Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

80 W Neck RdShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $1,228,000

Living Area 1,508 SqFt

Beds 2

Baths 1.5

Year Built 1958

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Individual

APN 0702-014.00-01.00-046.000

Neighborhood Shelter Island

School District Shelter Island Union Free School District

12 Petticoat LnShelter Island, NY 11964

Estimated Value $2,305,000

Living Area 2,528 SqFt

Beds 3