Residential Property Data Records on Bay St, Sterling, NY

We found 4 addresses on Bay St, Sterling, NY.

447 Bay StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $357,000
Living Area 1,340 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1889

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 11.08-1-18.1
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

451 Bay StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $458,000
Living Area 1,572 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1930

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 11.08-1-19.1
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

475 Bay StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $974,000
Living Area 3,660 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 2
Year Built 1988

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 055601 11.08-1-22
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

491 Bay StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $766,000
Living Area 2,405 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 3.5
Year Built 1915

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 11.08-1-24
Subdivision Hunts Point

School District Red Creek Central School District

Investment Properties near on Bay St, Sterling, NY

14616 Lake StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $250,000
Living Area 924 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1914

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple

APN 055601 9.13-1-7.21
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

463 Bay StFair Haven, NY 13064

Estimated Value $539,000
Living Area 2,532 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 2.5
Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 11.08-1-20.2
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

14562 Lake StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $189,000
Living Area 1,480 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1908

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate

APN 055601 9.13-1-17
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

14469 Fancher AveFair Haven, NY 13064

Estimated Value $223,000
Living Area 1,528 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1910

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 8.20-1-37.1
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

8783 Blind Sodus Bay RdRed Creek, NY 13143

Estimated Value $199,000
Living Area 1,689 SqFt

Beds 5
Baths 1
Year Built 1832

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 544889 78120-00-236772
Municipality WOLCOTT (TOV)

School District Red Creek Central School District

14462 Lake StFair Haven, NY 13064

Estimated Value $166,000
Living Area 1,939 SqFt

Beds 4
Baths 1
Year Built 1850

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple

APN 055601 9.17-1-18
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

14651 Cayuga StFair Haven, NY 13064

Estimated Value $158,000
Living Area 960 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1989

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 9.13-1-36.2
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

14553 Lake StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $197,000
Living Area 2,244 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1890

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 8.20-2-41.11
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

14427 S Lake StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $186,000
Living Area 1,269 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 2007

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 11.08-2-14.22
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

14485 Fancher AveFair Haven, NY 13064

Estimated Value $329,000
Living Area 1,494 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1898

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 8.20-1-23
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

14027 Smith RdSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $258,000
Living Area 1,704 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1985

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 544889 78120-00-378654
Municipality WOLCOTT (TOV)

School District Red Creek Central School District

14664 Lake StFair Haven, NY 13064

Estimated Value $262,000
Living Area 1,151 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1970

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 055601 9.13-1-1
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

14529 Fancher AveFair Haven, NY 13064

Estimated Value $988,000
Living Area 1,284 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2.5
Year Built 1978

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple

APN 055601 8.20-2-3
Subdivision Fair Haven

School District Red Creek Central School District

539 Wilcox StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $188,000
Living Area 1,146 SqFt

Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1800

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 055601 11.08-2-37
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

629 7th StFair Haven, NY 13064

Estimated Value $284,000
Living Area 2,051 SqFt

Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1950

Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual

APN 055601 9.09-1-49
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

14980 Lake St ExtFair Haven, NY 13064

Estimated Value $238,000
Living Area 2,297 SqFt

Beds 6
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1920

Property Type Cabin/Vacation Residence
Ownership Type Corporate

APN 055601 6.17-1-8
Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

Streets Near Bay St, Sterling, NY

Street

Properties

Avg. Beds

Avg. Baths

Avg. Property Value

Avg. Property Size

Last Sale Date

Bay Rd11832$299,2991,775 Sq.Ft.4/4/2025Blind Sodus Bay Rd6922$211,0481,274 Sq.Ft.5/12/2025Broadway Rd4821$151,6831,339 Sq.Ft.4/2/2025Creek Rd6021$138,6252,375 Sq.Ft.8/16/2024Fancher Ave6831$277,8451,344 Sq.Ft.11/18/2024Fancher Ave5532$357,6401,522 Sq.Ft.6/25/2024Lake St5831$220,4461,676 Sq.Ft.3/31/2025Old State Rd6832$262,6811,690 Sq.Ft.12/16/2024State Route 104a8832$332,3181,810 Sq.Ft.11/25/2024Sterling Station Rd5832$251,0941,715 Sq.Ft.5/12/2025

Additional Questions?

Looking for off-market properties in Sterling, NY?

Traditional methods include networking with contractors, scouting neighborhoods ("driving for dollars"), or purchasing leads from wholesalers can be tedious. PropertyReach streamlines this process with predictive analytics and neighborhood benchmarks, using Sterling, NY property records and MLS failed listings to refine your search. Effortlessly compare properties, access owner contact details, and secure the best off-market deals at the right price.

What is the median home value in Sterling, NY?

The median home value in Sterling, NY is $222,500, with an average home value of $270,089. The average price per square foot for homes in the area is $90.59.

How Can I Find Pre-foreclosures or Distressed Properties in Sterling, NY?

Foreclosures and distressed properties in Sterling, NY can be found through public records, foreclosure notices, and auction announcements from the county clerk or sheriff’s office. PropertyReach streamlines this by aggregating public and MLS data, making it easier to identify distressed properties and connect with owners directly.

Residential Property Data Records on Bay St, Sterling, NY

We found 4 addresses on Bay St, Sterling, NY.

447 Bay StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $357,000

Living Area 1,340 SqFt

Beds 4

Baths 1.5

Year Built 1889

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 11.08-1-18.1

Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

451 Bay StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $458,000

Living Area 1,572 SqFt

Beds 3

Baths 1

Year Built 1930

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 11.08-1-19.1

Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

475 Bay StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $974,000

Living Area 3,660 SqFt

Beds 4

Baths 2

Year Built 1988

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Individual

APN 055601 11.08-1-22

Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

491 Bay StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $766,000

Living Area 2,405 SqFt

Beds 4

Baths 3.5

Year Built 1915

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 11.08-1-24

Subdivision Hunts Point

School District Red Creek Central School District

Trial Membership Gives You Complete Data Access

Property Lookup

Owner Lookup

Property Search

Owner Contact Information

Property Comps

Market Trends

Investment Properties near on Bay St, Sterling, NY

14616 Lake StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $250,000

Living Area 924 SqFt

Beds 3

Baths 1

Year Built 1914

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Multiple

APN 055601 9.13-1-7.21

Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

463 Bay StFair Haven, NY 13064

Estimated Value $539,000

Living Area 2,532 SqFt

Beds 4

Baths 2.5

Year Built 1900

Property Type Single Family

Ownership Type Related

APN 055601 11.08-1-20.2

Municipality FAIR HAVEN

School District Red Creek Central School District

14562 Lake StSterling, NY 13156

Estimated Value $189,000

Living Area 1,480 SqFt

Beds 3