Shelter Island New York Property Records & Home PricesPopular Streets in Shelter Island, New York
Brander Pkwy9333$2,106,5002,261 Sq.Ft.12/30/2022Cartwright Rd10732$1,665,4171,859 Sq.Ft.3/5/2025Ferry Rd26932$1,889,0842,892 Sq.Ft.1/24/2025Gardiners Bay Dr6343$2,378,8934,748 Sq.Ft.12/23/2024Menantic Rd9032$1,858,7322,031 Sq.Ft.1/9/2025Midway Rd16832$1,960,1252,160 Sq.Ft.3/12/2025Neck Rd9232$1,577,6973,247 Sq.Ft.8/8/2024Peconic Ave9743$2,445,3632,676 Sq.Ft.9/12/2024Ram Island Dr11844$3,806,1633,741 Sq.Ft.3/23/2022Tuthill Dr6343$3,273,4812,680 Sq.Ft.8/28/2024All Streets in Shelter Island, New York
Thompson Rd1733$1,953,6472,252 Sq.Ft.7/12/2024Tims Trl1932$1,375,2221,876 Sq.Ft.2/28/2023Tower Hill Ave933$1,336,2502,345 Sq.Ft.4/9/2024Tuthill Dr6343$3,273,4812,680 Sq.Ft.8/28/2024Underwater2N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AUnder Water28N/AN/AN/AN/A12/12/2008Underwater Land1N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AValley Rd832$1,382,0001,929 Sq.Ft.10/21/2016Wade Rd1432$1,688,4291,714 Sq.Ft.4/1/2021Ward St442$1,745,2502,007 Sq.Ft.4/30/2014Washington St452$1,816,7502,591 Sq.Ft.12/28/2007Waverly Pl343$1,513,6672,010 Sq.Ft.8/8/2019Wesley Ave1542$1,651,8572,268 Sq.Ft.5/19/2022Westmoreland Dr5144$3,570,6603,674 Sq.Ft.3/5/2024West Neck Rd1N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AWestview Rd132$1,547,0003,116 Sq.Ft.4/16/2002Wheeler Rd2743$1,655,4446,892 Sq.Ft.10/19/2024White Birch Pl132$1,523,0001,968 Sq.Ft.5/22/2020White Birch Rd732$1,451,5001,801 Sq.Ft.7/19/2022Williette Rd332$1,535,3331,596 Sq.Ft.9/3/2013Willow Ln453$2,178,5002,789 Sq.Ft.1/20/2010Willow Pond Ln265N/A4,890 Sq.Ft.2/27/2003Willow Pond Rd333$2,486,0002,905 Sq.Ft.4/27/2018Winthrop Rd4343$2,215,6254,353 Sq.Ft.5/12/2023Woodbine Way443$1,621,5003,147 Sq.Ft.8/18/2014Worthy Way2032$1,404,7501,654 Sq.Ft.9/26/2023Yoco Rd6N/AN/A$544,0001,569 Sq.Ft.N/A206 Center StGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $674,000
Living Area 1,025 SqFt
Beds 2
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1840
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple
APN 1001-004.00-02.00-023.000
Municipality SOUTHOLD
School District Greenport Union Free School District
6 Wesley AveShelter Island Heights, NY 11965
Estimated Value $1,377,000
Living Area 1,932 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1890
Property Type Cabin/Vacation Residence
Ownership Type Multiple
APN 0702-005.00-04.00-013.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island Heights
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
31 S Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,417,000
Living Area 1,068 SqFt
Beds 2
Baths 2
Year Built 1942
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related
APN 0702-019.00-02.00-095.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
1955 Bay Shore RdGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $1,459,000
Living Area 2,500 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 3
Year Built 1998
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 1000-053.00-04.00-010.000
Neighborhood Greenport West
School District Greenport Union Free School District
432 1st StGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $1,087,000
Living Area 2,400 SqFt
Beds 4
Baths 2.5
Year Built 1888
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 1001-004.00-07.00-002.001
Subdivision Beebe Ests
School District Greenport Union Free School District
424 4th StGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $1,118,000
Living Area 1,972 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1973
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related
APN 1001-006.00-06.00-017.000
Municipality SOUTHOLD
School District Greenport Union Free School District
57 Peconic AveShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,788,000
Living Area 2,427 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1975
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate
APN 0702-025.00-01.00-040.001
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
2030 Bay Shore RdGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $879,000
Living Area 1,100 SqFt
Beds 2
Baths 1
Year Built 1950
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related
APN 1000-053.00-04.00-027.000
Neighborhood Greenport West
School District Greenport Union Free School District
42 Stearns Point RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,787,000
Living Area 5,175 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 4
Year Built 2008
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-013.00-02.00-025.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
325 Wiggins StGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $781,000
Living Area 1,456 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1985
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate
APN 1001-006.00-04.00-011.000
Municipality SOUTHOLD
School District Greenport Union Free School District
2295 Bay Shore RdGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $1,230,000
Living Area 1,050 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1953
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related
APN 1000-053.00-04.00-015.000
Neighborhood Greenport West
School District Greenport Union Free School District
142 S Midway RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,282,000
Living Area 1,612 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2.5
Year Built 2001
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Mixed
APN 0702-023.00-02.00-090.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
2 Fox Hollow RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $2,178,000
Living Area 5,219 SqFt
Beds 5
Baths 2
Year Built 2018
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-019.00-02.00-113.003
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
512 5th StGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $714,000
Living Area 1,300 SqFt
Beds 2
Baths 2
Year Built 1873
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple
APN 1001-006.00-02.00-003.000
Municipality SOUTHOLD
School District Greenport Union Free School District
171 5th StGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $1,196,000
Living Area 1,520 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1920
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple
APN 1001-007.00-04.00-015.000
Municipality SOUTHOLD
School District Greenport Union Free School District
20 Oyster PtGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $1,413,000
Living Area 2,300 SqFt
Beds 4
Baths 2
Year Built 1986
Property Type Apt House 5+ Units
Ownership Type Related
APN 1001-007.01-01.00-020.000
Subdivision Oyster Point
School District Greenport Union Free School District