Shelter Island New York Property Records & Home PricesPopular Streets in Shelter Island, New York
Brander Pkwy9333$2,106,5002,261 Sq.Ft.12/30/2022Cartwright Rd10732$1,665,4171,859 Sq.Ft.3/5/2025Ferry Rd26932$1,889,0842,892 Sq.Ft.1/24/2025Gardiners Bay Dr6343$2,378,8934,748 Sq.Ft.12/23/2024Menantic Rd9032$1,858,7322,031 Sq.Ft.1/9/2025Midway Rd16832$1,960,1252,160 Sq.Ft.3/12/2025Neck Rd9232$1,577,6973,247 Sq.Ft.8/8/2024Peconic Ave9743$2,445,3632,676 Sq.Ft.9/12/2024Ram Island Dr11844$3,806,1633,741 Sq.Ft.3/23/2022Tuthill Dr6343$3,273,4812,680 Sq.Ft.8/28/2024All Streets in Shelter Island, New York
Little Cedar Is2N/AN/A$866,000N/A4/5/2012Little Ram Island Dr2245$5,728,7505,310 Sq.Ft.12/16/2020Livingston Dr1N/AN/A$378,000N/AN/ALocust Ave443$1,827,0002,436 Sq.Ft.5/31/2022Locust Point Rd855$4,247,7505,306 Sq.Ft.6/18/2021Locust Rd342$1,559,5001,368 Sq.Ft.5/6/2010Locust Woods Dr1444$3,354,0913,785 Sq.Ft.8/9/2017Lords Ln554$3,787,0004,083 Sq.Ft.3/11/2014Manhanset Rd3933$2,237,2942,788 Sq.Ft.10/28/2023Manwaring Rd1243$1,301,8892,772 Sq.Ft.8/10/2021Marc St1632$1,589,7501,598 Sq.Ft.9/27/2024Margarets Dr2144$2,757,9503,098 Sq.Ft.6/17/2024Mastic Rd1N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AMeadow Pl1042$736,4002,637 Sq.Ft.1/18/2017Meadow St122$1,964,0001,320 Sq.Ft.N/AMenantic1N/AN/A$833,000N/AN/AMenantic Rd9032$1,858,7322,031 Sq.Ft.1/9/2025Merkel Ln1933$1,710,1672,306 Sq.Ft.7/14/2022Midway Rd16832$1,960,1252,160 Sq.Ft.3/12/2025Mimosa Pl1032$1,325,2001,909 Sq.Ft.12/16/2024Montclair Ave1343$3,655,0003,235 Sq.Ft.7/1/2022Myrtle Rd522$796,6672,140 Sq.Ft.11/13/2019Neck Rd9232$1,577,6973,247 Sq.Ft.8/8/2024Neds Ln633$4,160,0005,760 Sq.Ft.2/20/2020New York Ave1932$1,392,6472,206 Sq.Ft.9/28/2022N Ferry Rd1N/AN/AN/AN/A1/11/1996Nicoll Rd744$2,350,8333,380 Sq.Ft.5/27/2010Nostrand Pkwy2754$4,412,7374,129 Sq.Ft.12/18/2023Oak Rd2N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AOak Tree Ln544$3,538,6673,464 Sq.Ft.4/24/2019Oakwood Ave144$2,088,0002,796 Sq.Ft.12/16/2019Ole Buck Run932$1,258,6671,753 Sq.Ft.4/2/2024Orchard Rd242$1,483,5001,279 Sq.Ft.7/14/2014Osprey Ln1033$1,278,5712,461 Sq.Ft.9/30/2021Osprey Rd2833$1,603,2692,290 Sq.Ft.12/13/2022Overlook Pl5N/AN/A$992,000N/AN/AOxford Ave442$1,945,7502,175 Sq.Ft.4/11/2006Pandion Rd855$3,449,8005,973 Sq.Ft.8/4/2022Peconic Ave9743$2,445,3632,676 Sq.Ft.9/12/2024Pennys Path1632$1,383,5631,941 Sq.Ft.2/21/2024Peppermill Ln1032$1,763,8002,037 Sq.Ft.7/27/2023Petticoat Ln1342$1,569,9172,272 Sq.Ft.5/4/2023Pheasant Ln1333$2,516,7272,560 Sq.Ft.3/31/2017Plaza Dr1N/AN/A$846,000N/AN/APoint Ln1243$2,731,2503,503 Sq.Ft.8/25/2022Primrose Pl443$1,587,0002,562 Sq.Ft.6/29/2016Proposed Rd277$6,812,00010,708 Sq.Ft.11/5/1996Prospect Ave3043$2,850,0402,816 Sq.Ft.7/17/2017Quail Hedge133$1,906,0003,510 Sq.Ft.7/25/2002Quail Hedge Ln644$1,887,6009,859 Sq.Ft.5/26/2022Quail Run932$1,485,8892,244 Sq.Ft.12/1/2020Quaker Path1633$1,559,4672,506 Sq.Ft.5/23/2021Rainbow Cir2N/AN/A$626,000N/AN/ARam Island Dr11844$3,806,1633,741 Sq.Ft.3/23/2022Ram Island Rd4233$2,619,8132,259 Sq.Ft.11/6/2024Rebel Rd832$1,400,1431,615 Sq.Ft.3/11/2016Robin Ln933$1,408,1111,912 Sq.Ft.4/29/2020Rocky Point Rd1833$2,438,8752,758 Sq.Ft.11/12/2024Rocky Point Ter743$2,270,7502,350 Sq.Ft.5/5/2022Sandpiper Rd1133$1,636,0912,119 Sq.Ft.11/5/2020School St632$1,823,7501,959 Sq.Ft.5/14/2002Seagate Dr433$2,410,2503,083 Sq.Ft.6/20/2011Seagate Rd1N/AN/A$704,000N/AN/ASea Gull Rd843$2,255,6002,029 Sq.Ft.3/11/2025Seagull Rd443$3,333,5002,435 Sq.Ft.5/2/2013Serpentine Dr1533$2,042,7502,617 Sq.Ft.2/1/2022S Ferry Rd7N/AN/A$680,000N/AN/ASheep Pasture Ln643$1,681,1671,859 Sq.Ft.7/14/2023Shelterlands Path2132$1,734,2142,155 Sq.Ft.7/18/2022Shore Rd3243$1,499,3915,907 Sq.Ft.9/3/2021Shorewood Ct244$4,150,0004,175 Sq.Ft.N/AShorewood Rd1744$3,374,3533,720 Sq.Ft.1/12/2023Silver Beach Rd833$2,050,2502,057 Sq.Ft.3/13/2020Simpson Ave633$1,888,2002,070 Sq.Ft.11/8/2013Simpson Rd122$1,378,000892 Sq.Ft.2/8/2008Simpson St243$3,799,5002,893 Sq.Ft.1/10/2018Sleepy Hollow Rd1242$1,619,0832,203 Sq.Ft.2/22/2022Smith St5232$1,482,9801,593 Sq.Ft.3/11/2025South St242$1,432,5002,247 Sq.Ft.12/18/2020Southwick Ln1433$2,224,7782,338 Sq.Ft.6/7/2024Spring Garden Ave1543$2,022,2312,414 Sq.Ft.3/27/2024Stearns Point Rd4633$1,772,4442,846 Sq.Ft.2/13/2025St James St121$1,736,0001,062 Sq.Ft.4/8/2002St Johns St654$1,708,2502,456 Sq.Ft.9/27/2007St Marys Rd3032$1,934,7142,113 Sq.Ft.2/21/2020Strawberry Ln1532$1,500,0001,819 Sq.Ft.11/15/2021Strobel Rd332$1,380,6671,879 Sq.Ft.6/21/2023Summerfield Pl853$2,545,0003,444 Sq.Ft.11/6/2000Sunnyside Ave1054$1,799,8573,244 Sq.Ft.11/16/2021Sunset Ln432$1,189,3331,653 Sq.Ft.3/15/2024Sunshine Rd1933$2,137,5002,571 Sq.Ft.1/31/2024Sylvan Pl142$1,538,0002,073 Sq.Ft.5/24/1998Sylvan Rd2443$1,846,5452,138 Sq.Ft.5/28/2024Sylvester Rd556$3,979,8008,047 Sq.Ft.2/25/2023T1N/AN/AN/AN/AN/ATarkettle Rd1732$2,376,0592,123 Sq.Ft.10/20/2021Tennis Court Ln432$1,049,5001,314 Sq.Ft.10/6/2021Terry Dr2843$1,364,5562,379 Sq.Ft.5/3/2024Thomas Ave832$1,430,8331,890 Sq.Ft.6/8/2018Thomas St3132$1,779,7591,824 Sq.Ft.12/12/202319 Peconic AveShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,354,000
Living Area 1,431 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1969
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-021.00-01.00-035.002
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
220 Oak StGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $943,000
Living Area 1,625 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1950
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Trust
APN 1000-042.00-01.00-023.000
Neighborhood Greenport West
School District Greenport Union Free School District
14 Congdon RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,854,000
Living Area 4,424 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2.5
Year Built 2002
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Trust
APN 0702-015.00-04.00-075.005
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
236 6th AveGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $838,000
Living Area 1,530 SqFt
Beds 4
Baths 1
Year Built 1947
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple
APN 1001-004.00-04.00-022.000
Subdivision Thomas F Price
School District Greenport Union Free School District
4 Dawn LnShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $4,982,000
Living Area 5,597 SqFt
Beds 8
Baths 6.5
Year Built 1970
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-001.00-02.00-070.002
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
129 N Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,254,000
Living Area 2,418 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1920
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-007.00-03.00-051.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
47 N Midway RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,402,000
Living Area 1,472 SqFt
Beds 2
Baths 2
Year Built 1931
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-014.00-03.00-067.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
505 Wiggins StGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $980,000
Living Area 1,850 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1850
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related
APN 1001-006.00-03.00-013.000
Municipality SOUTHOLD
School District Greenport Union Free School District
321 2nd StGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $786,000
Living Area 1,445 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1886
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 1001-004.00-06.00-017.000
Municipality SOUTHOLD
School District Greenport Union Free School District
3 Johnston RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $2,033,000
Living Area 1,473 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1977
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related
APN 0702-008.00-02.00-038.008
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
12 Emerson LnShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,414,000
Living Area 1,388 SqFt
Beds 2
Baths 2
Year Built 1982
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate
APN 0702-015.00-04.00-087.001
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
72 Ram Island DrShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $5,319,000
Living Area 3,379 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2.5
Year Built 2016
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-009.00-03.00-008.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
42 S Midway RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $2,399,000
Living Area 2,079 SqFt
Beds 4
Baths 3
Year Built 1944
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate
APN 0702-019.00-01.00-013.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
27 Bay Shore DrShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $3,992,000
Living Area 2,515 SqFt
Beds 4
Baths 3.5
Year Built 1956
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-022.00-01.00-108.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
420 6th StGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $624,000
Living Area 1,908 SqFt
Beds 4
Baths 3
Year Built 1933
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate
APN 0100-129.00-02.00-113.001
Subdivision Ezra Park
School District West Babylon Union Free School District
2B Smith StShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,340,000
Living Area 1,175 SqFt
Beds 1
Baths 1.5
Year Built 2001
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-015.00-03.00-098.001
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District