Shelter Island New York Property Records & Home PricesPopular Streets in Shelter Island, New York
Brander Pkwy9333$2,106,5002,261 Sq.Ft.12/30/2022Cartwright Rd10732$1,665,4171,859 Sq.Ft.4/11/2025Ferry Rd26932$1,889,0842,892 Sq.Ft.1/24/2025Gardiners Bay Dr6343$2,378,8934,748 Sq.Ft.12/23/2024Menantic Rd9032$1,858,7322,031 Sq.Ft.1/9/2025Midway Rd16832$1,960,1252,160 Sq.Ft.3/12/2025Neck Rd9232$1,577,6973,247 Sq.Ft.8/8/2024Peconic Ave9743$2,445,3632,676 Sq.Ft.9/12/2024Ram Island Dr11844$3,806,1633,741 Sq.Ft.3/23/2022Tuthill Dr6343$3,273,4812,680 Sq.Ft.8/28/2024All Streets in Shelter Island, New York
A Gazon Rd1N/AN/A$540,000N/A10/1/2014Apple Orchard Ln347$8,616,0003,485 Sq.Ft.3/16/2021Artists Ln1042$1,390,7502,692 Sq.Ft.11/22/2016Auburn Pl343$1,864,0002,192 Sq.Ft.N/ABaldwin Rd3432$1,702,2591,994 Sq.Ft.8/31/2022Bartman Rd232$1,711,5001,682 Sq.Ft.7/20/2015Bateman Rd732$1,842,0002,095 Sq.Ft.11/13/2017Bay Ave642$1,630,3332,079 Sq.Ft.1/19/2017Bay Rd743$2,759,4292,659 Sq.Ft.12/19/2022Bay Shore Dr1833$2,822,5562,470 Sq.Ft.10/25/2016Bayview Ave444$2,781,7503,534 Sq.Ft.5/14/2020Behringer Ln732$1,615,0002,378 Sq.Ft.9/9/2024Behringer Rd2N/AN/A$596,000N/AN/ABelvedere Ave123$4,055,0001,909 Sq.Ft.N/ABevan Pl133$1,548,0001,798 Sq.Ft.N/AB Gazon Rd1N/AN/A$1,097,000N/AN/ABlueberry Ln632$1,356,2002,288 Sq.Ft.8/19/2013Bluff Ave743$2,044,8574,021 Sq.Ft.5/28/2024Bonnie Ln243$2,646,5004,072 Sq.Ft.6/16/2023Bootleggers Aly744$3,344,5004,611 Sq.Ft.4/15/2020Bowditch Rd1633$1,580,6672,429 Sq.Ft.6/22/2023Brander Pkwy9333$2,106,5002,261 Sq.Ft.12/30/2022Burns Rd3332$1,516,4641,759 Sq.Ft.1/20/2025Burro Hall Ln1033$1,846,0002,329 Sq.Ft.1/12/2022Carlton Rd143$2,027,0002,758 Sq.Ft.9/9/1998Carousel Ln143$2,471,0001,504 Sq.Ft.N/ACartwright Rd10732$1,665,4171,859 Sq.Ft.4/11/2025Cedar Ave1N/AN/A$531,000N/AN/AC Gazon Rd1N/AN/A$624,000N/A12/2/2015Charlies Ln854$4,423,1434,081 Sq.Ft.8/24/2023Chase Ave1042$1,637,2502,521 Sq.Ft.3/25/2022Chequit Ave1254$2,296,7503,436 Sq.Ft.11/26/2021Cherry Ln1N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AClinton Ave1554$2,883,5003,125 Sq.Ft.11/24/2021Club Dr843$3,721,2003,825 Sq.Ft.11/23/2022Cobbetts Ln2643$2,122,6673,271 Sq.Ft.8/9/2022Coecles Pl643$2,044,8003,188 Sq.Ft.3/10/2005Community Dr532$1,720,6002,322 Sq.Ft.2/5/2021Congdon Rd2832$1,648,9631,999 Sq.Ft.4/10/2023Conrad Rd643$2,022,1672,374 Sq.Ft.12/18/2019Country Club Dr4733$1,772,0702,569 Sq.Ft.5/13/2025Cove Way1133$3,352,4442,628 Sq.Ft.9/19/2024Cozy Ln1132$1,428,6001,567 Sq.Ft.6/26/2024Crab Creek Rd1332$1,484,8331,740 Sq.Ft.4/22/2024Crescent Beach Rd132$1,841,0002,420 Sq.Ft.6/1/1998Crescent Way2233$1,497,0002,356 Sq.Ft.10/18/2024Daniel Lord Rd232$1,674,0001,722 Sq.Ft.3/6/2020Dawn Ln168$4,752,0006,733 Sq.Ft.8/28/2020Deer Park Ln534$2,058,8003,242 Sq.Ft.10/24/2022Dering Woods Ln545$5,537,0004,834 Sq.Ft.11/22/2024Dering Woods Rd544$2,964,50069,298 Sq.Ft.8/28/2024D Gazon Rd1N/AN/A$624,000N/AN/ADickerson Dr2733$2,418,8002,661 Sq.Ft.10/10/2022Dinah Rock Rd4133$1,971,3162,724 Sq.Ft.12/8/2022Dogwood Ln542$1,499,7502,279 Sq.Ft.2/13/2020Duvall Ave421$1,795,0001,473 Sq.Ft.11/29/2021Emerson Ln1132$1,725,1821,677 Sq.Ft.8/19/2022Evans Rd1232$1,368,7271,679 Sq.Ft.8/22/2024Ferry Rd26932$1,889,0842,892 Sq.Ft.1/24/2025Fox Hollow Rd1043$2,184,5003,058 Sq.Ft.3/13/2023Fox Hollow Run1N/AN/A$821,000N/A4/12/2002Freds Ln2243$1,970,4292,828 Sq.Ft.7/27/2021Fresh Pond1N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AGardiners Bay Dr6343$2,378,8934,748 Sq.Ft.12/23/2024Gardiner Way663$3,434,0003,134 Sq.Ft.4/21/2006Gazon Rd743$1,667,0002,485 Sq.Ft.12/2/2015Gibb Ave232$1,210,5001,474 Sq.Ft.11/22/2016Ginny Dr1332$2,221,0001,760 Sq.Ft.4/20/2016Glynn Dr1843$1,374,5562,083 Sq.Ft.5/17/2024Graces Ln344$4,339,0003,517 Sq.Ft.9/27/2001Grand Ave3043$1,748,2503,549 Sq.Ft.8/22/2024Great Circle Dr1343$1,586,5382,539 Sq.Ft.1/17/2025Great Circle Rd1533$1,515,8672,366 Sq.Ft.6/17/2022Hagar Rd1433$2,105,6431,954 Sq.Ft.4/1/2021Harbor Ln2655$2,597,3334,268 Sq.Ft.6/6/2024Havens Rd1N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AHay Beach Rd1343$1,578,9232,419 Sq.Ft.5/3/2021Hedges Rd142$1,292,0001,761 Sq.Ft.N/AHeritage Dr833$2,124,3332,425 Sq.Ft.9/26/2018Heron Ln943$2,040,2862,362 Sq.Ft.9/20/2004Hillcrest Rd733$1,298,5712,217 Sq.Ft.4/4/2016Hillside Dr1443$1,585,9232,349 Sq.Ft.12/13/2023Hilo Dr3043$2,392,1002,819 Sq.Ft.5/7/2024Hudson Ave1122$1,536,3331,678 Sq.Ft.3/26/2021Ians Ln34N/A$1,729,0002,971 Sq.Ft.N/AIndustrial Rd1N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AIrene Ln1042$1,479,6672,027 Sq.Ft.4/16/2019Island Way1443$1,308,0004,011 Sq.Ft.3/12/2024Ivy Pl133N/A1,487 Sq.Ft.3/6/2007Jaspa Rd2222$1,733,8421,379 Sq.Ft.3/18/2021Jennings Old Ln1N/AN/A$826,000N/AN/AJohnston Rd832$1,842,8752,053 Sq.Ft.2/25/2021Joy Dr732$1,017,3331,214 Sq.Ft.7/15/1998Lake Dr4233$1,788,9052,205 Sq.Ft.2/27/2025Lakeview Dr1633$1,489,1432,102 Sq.Ft.4/21/2022Landing Ln345$4,744,0005,097 Sq.Ft.5/18/2020Lari Ln954$4,987,0004,658 Sq.Ft.9/29/2021Lilliput Ln1033$1,558,0002,265 Sq.Ft.4/1/2021Linda Ct1332$1,436,3851,770 Sq.Ft.8/2/2023Linda Rd322$1,678,6672,001 Sq.Ft.4/27/20174 Crescent WayShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,482,000
Living Area 2,599 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2.5
Year Built 1987
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple
APN 0702-001.00-01.00-084.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
8 Wesley AveShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,386,000
Living Area 2,887 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 3.5
Year Built 1872
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate
APN 0702-005.00-04.00-020.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
68 Gardiners Bay DrShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $2,761,000
Living Area 1,921 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1970
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related
APN 0702-001.00-02.00-063.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
90 Gardiners Bay DrShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $3,117,000
Living Area 5,064 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 5.5
Year Built 2001
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate
APN 0702-001.00-02.00-053.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
117 Ram Island DrShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $4,011,000
Living Area 4,410 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 3.5
Year Built 2005
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-010.00-01.00-002.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
8 Strawberry LnShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,474,000
Living Area 1,991 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 2002
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-019.00-02.00-027.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
46 W Neck RdShelter Island Heights, NY 11965
Estimated Value $1,016,000
Living Area 1,560 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1992
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0900-111.00-03.00-019.003
Neighborhood Shelter Island Heights
School District Tuckahoe Common School District
20D N Cartwright RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,798,000
Living Area 1,154 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1960
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate
APN 0702-016.00-02.00-002.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
129 N Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,254,000
Living Area 2,418 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 1.5
Year Built 1920
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-007.00-03.00-051.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
7 Tower Hill AveShelter Island Heights, NY 11965
Estimated Value $1,007,000
Living Area 1,162 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 1
Year Built 1920
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Multiple
APN 0702-006.00-04.00-002.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island Heights
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
4 Chase AveShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,353,000
Living Area 2,194 SqFt
Beds 4
Baths 2
Year Built 1890
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related
APN 0702-005.00-06.00-011.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
5 Bay AveShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,304,000
Living Area 1,270 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 3
Year Built 1951
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related
APN 0702-022.00-02.00-042.000
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
72 S Ferry RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,290,000
Living Area 1,500 SqFt
Beds 1
Baths 1
Year Built 1998
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Corporate
APN 0702-019.00-02.00-122.002
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
2105 Bay Shore RdGreenport, NY 11944
Estimated Value $1,925,000
Living Area 2,400 SqFt
Beds 4
Baths 3
Year Built 1960
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Related
APN 1000-053.00-04.00-013.000
Neighborhood Greenport West
School District Greenport Union Free School District
64 Ram Island DrShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $2,697,000
Living Area 5,912 SqFt
Beds 4
Baths 6
Year Built 2000
Property Type Residential General
Ownership Type Multiple
APN 0702-008.00-03.00-001.010
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District
40 Ram Island RdShelter Island, NY 11964
Estimated Value $1,627,000
Living Area 1,594 SqFt
Beds 3
Baths 2
Year Built 1852
Property Type Single Family
Ownership Type Individual
APN 0702-008.00-03.00-008.001
Neighborhood Shelter Island
School District Shelter Island Union Free School District